Bro a Brahmgyani knows more than you or I, Rakhri is routed in Vedic traditions and is Vedic Ritual. Why do you constantly ignore Guru Gobind Singh Ji's words at rejecting the. I just showed you its a Vedic Tradition but you're still hellbent on ignoring it. That is manmat.
You're the one ignoring Gurbani, Gurbani teaches you a Mahapurkh has blended with the lord, by disrespecting and ignoring their words (and doing their nindya as you are doing right now) you're rejecting Guru Granth Sahib Ji altogether.
What the actual hell lol, why are you mocking them now? Phones are a creation of human ingenuity (through Waheguru's grace), learn the meaning of Nirgun before casually passing that word around. Nirgun= without attributes. Sound is an attribute. Nir=without gun=attributes.
Read any of the Purantan Granths, Mahapurkh's speech is 100% truth. None of them have ever said stop reading Gurbani and listen to us, that's what makes them true Brahmgyanis. Did you read the Astapdhi's regarding Brahmgyani's and Saadhs in Sukhmani Sahib? did you see where it it said They are one with the lord, why are you disrespecting the lord by ignoring their words.
Do you actually know where Rakhri comes from? do you know the actual story behind it in the purana? No you don't. Because if you did you wouldn't sit here and scream its not religious and you would know WHY its considered a Spiritual thread? I suggest reading up and learning before coming here to debate this, its apparent you have no gyan on where the tradition arose from.
The thread is meant to provide Spiritual and worldly protection which a thread can't do.
Rehitname aren't Gurbani, I asked for Gurbani proof, you can't provide it. The fact that you are trying to use them shows your own lack of thought as you have no idea WHY these Rehits came into being and the historical context behind them. Gurbani is so clear that a Sant is one with the lord but since they don't speak what you want them you lump them as Pakhandi Babe, you tried in this thread to disrespect Sant Isher Singh ji by saying he was telling people to pooj portraits of Guru Nanak Dev JI based on what his current Jatha is doing. IN this thread alone you've made countless statements which have shown to be false however your own manmat has lead you to do Nindya of a Sant and mock other Saints as well.
Gurbani teaches you to learn from them. In the congregation of Saints is god found (Sukkhmani Sahib), Do not tell others to learn Gurbani when you don't want to do it yourself.
Question. Yes or NO. do you consider Guru Gobind Singh Ji your Guru, if you do then you'll reject Rakhri due to it being a Vedic tradition since he told his Sikhs to reject them. If you still want insist you know more than Guru Gobind Singh and follow it through then go for it.
@singhbj I've not belittled anyone. You're a massive hypocrite, that isn't me doing any form of Nindya, its stating a fact. Nindya= falsehood. You said we should listen to our parents and follow their rules but chickened out when I asked if you'd cut your Kesh if your parents told you to. Re-evaluate your thoughts before throwing such hypocritical statements around. IN this thread alone you called me a freeloader and a bad child because I was trying to live a proper Rehit life. Bro, the fact that your Grandfather forced him to take it shows he's just as big as Patit as your cousin.
For the Sangat who wish to learn where it originated from please refer to this.
Why it is a Spiritual thread and in many places such as here.
http://www.drikpanchang.com/festivals/raksha-bandhan/info/raksha-bandhan-puja-vidhi.html
http://www.dlshq.org/religions/raksha.htm
http://www.shreehindutemple.net/hinduism/raksha-bandhan/
http://www.drikpanchang.com/festivals/raksha-bandhan/raksha-bandhan-date-time.html?l=9103
These are all links from "Non-Sikh Missionary" sites. They clearly state how its routed in being a Spiritual thread, I'm really done with this thread, can be locked. I've provided testaments from seasoned Gursikhs along with actual proof how it is Routed in old Hindu Puranas, @Akalifauj provided how the Gurbani was misconstructed and countless others pointed out the Sheer hypocrisy being displayed here. Seems like people don't even know what a word as simple as Nirgun means.
ਪਾਂਇਗਹੇਜਬਤੇਤੁਮਰੇਤਬਤੇਕੋਊਆਂਖਤਰੇਨਹੀਆਨਿਯੋ॥ਰਾਮਰਹੀਮਪੁਰਾਨਕੁਰਾਨਅਨੇਕਕਹੈਂਮਤਿਏਕਨਮਾਨਿਯੋ॥पांइगहेजबतेतुमरेतबतेकोऊआंखतरेनहीआनियो॥रामरहीमपुरानकुरानअनेककहैंमतिएकनमानियो॥
O God ! the day when I caught hold of your feet, I do not bring anyone else under my sight; none other is liked by me now; the Puranas and the Quran try to know Thee by the names of Ram and Rahim and talk about you through several stories, but I do not accept any of their opinions;
ਸਿੰਮ੍ਰਿਤਿਸਾਸਤ੍ਰਬੇਦਸਭੈਬਹੁਭੇਦਕਹੈਹਮਏਕਨਜਾਨਿਯੋ॥ਸ੍ਰੀਅਸਿਪਾਨਿਕ੍ਰਿਪਾਤੁਮਰੀਕਰਿਮੈਨਕਹਿਯੋਸਭਤੋਹਿਬਖਾਨਿਯੋ॥੮੬੩॥सिम्रितिसासत्रबेदसभैबहुभेदकहैहमएकनजानियो॥स्रीअसिपानिक्रिपातुमरीकरिमैनकहियोसभतोहिबखानियो॥८६३॥
The Simritis, Shastras and Vedas describe several mysteries of yours, but I do not agree with any of them. O sword-wielder God! This all has been described by Thy Grace, what power can I have to write all this?.863.
If Guru Gobind Singh Ji told us not to indulge in all this then please lets not. If anyone wishes to contridict Guru Sahib with their own anmat then they may do so, they have every right. However they can't proclaim to be Sikhs or even consider that as Gurmat.
Thread can be locked
↧