There is absolutely no logic behind what you are saying. You want one of two people who practise Jhatka to Jhatka the other so they can understand the feelings that are involved in this practise? That’s dreadfully illogical, verging on anarchy that is.
“Murder of a goat” isn’t a thing and the killing of humans isn’t inhumane and horrendous just because the law tells us so. Are you not shocked when an animal kills an innocent human?
Intelligence of sentient beings should be taken into account.
You seem to be forgetting that human life is the highest Joon. Goats and humans are not comparable at all on a Karmic level.
If soldier kills a fellow soldier that means there is one less person to propagate Dharam. If a soldier kills a goat as part of a soldier lifestyle for both physical and mental purposes then that goat has indirectly helped the propagating of Dharam.
Can goats propagate Dharam alone? Can a goat get Mukti on its own?
You’re likening Jhatka to torture or similar.
I told you about the tabla and rabab, who do you think provides these materials?
Don’t forget how many innocent defenceless animals lives are taken by us involuntarily, many by everyday processes and activities. Why is killing one voluntarily such a heinous crime especially given the value of it as listed in my earlier post?
I can agree with your last point but I pretty much summed it up when I said courage (Bir Rass) and skill (SV and Jhatka) are two different things. A tyrant can have much courage and skill also, but if there is not righteousness behind that courage or skill then he will have to answer for his actions one day.
↧